Buying a Computer - Comments

What about choosing between intel and celeron as the processor. I noticed that celeron processor are cheaper. Any advantages or otherwise?

EDITOR'S NOTE: I assume you meant Intel Pentium vs Intel Celeron... No practical difference, unless you're a power user. Celeron has less on-board cache, so is a little slower but a little cheaper. AMD also makes processors which are highly regarded. Shop for speed, not brand, when looking for a CPU.

I've been a Macintosh user since 1986. Please take this piece of advice from somebody with extensive experience using both platforms: Macintosh computers are superior to Windows computers in every aspect.

You state that "Windows-based computers ... are cheaper." I think it's unrealistic to say that you can buy anything decent in the $400 range unless all you want to have is the computing equivalent of a Yugo. For $599 you can buy a Mac Mini (but without a monitor), which provides you with a very powerful computing platform.

With a Unix-based operating system that's far ahead of the curve, very intuitive interface, slick appearance, rock solid stability, and customization options, it is my humble opinion that only the uninformed computer buyer would purchase a Windows computer.

And you're quite welcome to your opinion! I won't host a Windows vs. Mac holy war here, but I beg to differ on a few points:

1) You can get a *HOT* windows-based PC with no monitor for under $500. A little looking around and I found 3GHz systems with 512MB RAM. There's nothing "Mini" about that.

2) My Windows XP system runs for months at a time. It only reboots when the power goes out.

3) Apple has less than 10% market share, and in the US, there's a much higher concentration of Mac users on the West coast. If you don't live there, finding local help or a service tech can be tough.

I've used Windows, Mac, Linux, AIX, OS/2 and other systems. They *ALL* offer easy point and click computing, and the users interfaces have much in common.

Macs may be cooler looking and more stable, but personally I think a Windows PC is the best choice for *most* new users.

You make a point I have underlined to everyone I ever advised on a computer purchase [though years ago, when the price-per-inch for monitors was much more wallet-busting than it is now, I can see that the advice was harder to take] -- get the biggest monitor you can ever afford. The reason being that the monitor is something you look at every day, you never can have enough screen space, and monitors last a long time -- I have had more than one monitor go through three successive system boxes underneath it -- and you can even switch from a Wintel box to a Mac if you like, and keep your monitor!

The first question any computer purchaser should always ask themselves is "What do you plan to do with it?". Newbies would need to have various usage categories suggested and maybe demonstrated to them of course.

The choice of video board is critical if there is any possibility of wanting to run 3D simulations or 3D games. Never under purchase if at all possible!

I've had this computer for 5 years, excepting the hard drive, and it's plenty fast for even the newest apps (not the original CPU either, but it doesn't matter because it was still available in 2001). A lot of times what matters is what components are used; not so much the age. I've seen a lot of those "bargain" computers not withstand the test of time because of poorly designed hardware that doesn't take full advantage of technologies, or uses "new" old stock components that the manufacturer is trying to use up.

So, one way to avoid this is to do some research before buying something. Do some Google searches to find out what people are saying about it. Buy the biggest hard drive you can possibly afford. Read the above comments about monitors and video cards and you should be all set.

I just read that LAPTOPS are outselling traditional desktop PCs for the first time. I have two laptops and the last one I got was a dang good one and it does every thing I need it to do. I am not a gamer but surf the web and design a few websites and blog. With a laptop you get everything in one little slim box, one of mine is a Toshiba Satellite M35XS114 I bought new a year ago and with all the discounts and rebates it came in around $600. It has a 1.3 Celeron M processor and doesn't consume much power. I added 512 meg to the 256 it came with for around $60 cause it was cheaper that way.

Maybe you could do a Laptop Buyers Guide some day!
Thanks for your article and not getting suck into a Windows vs. Mac holy war, after all they are just machines not Gods to worship! PS I loaded and dual boot Suse 10.0 and it found the modem!

Great answer and suggestions! Newbies are so fortunate, today. They get "more bang, for their buck" than those of us, who purchased our first computer back in the 90's.

In September 1997, I spent over $2100 for a Cyrix 166MHz CPU, 16MB SIMMS, 1.3GB hard drive, ViewSonic 15" monitor and an Epson Printer. The computer system was $1200, the monitor was $500 and the printer was $400. I had a friend with computer knowledge helping me and I bought through a catalog, so there were shipping and handling charges.

My friend also, taught me how to repair and upgrade, he was my mentor, then I learned more and would repair or tweak his computer. Plus, I learned how to repair, tweak, build and fix, after the age of 54. Not bad, for an old broad, is it?

Just look at the prices, you are suggesting. Today's computers are at least a thousand times more powerful, even the cheap ones! The prices you suggested are great for senior citizens. Many are on "fixed or limited" incomes, like I am today, and must save to purchase their first computer. Once again, great article and suggestions.

Bob, good article for newbies. Wish you would have mentioned that DIY PC's are almost always much better than store bought. The components have longer warranties, more expansion space, are upgradeable, and full feature software that's fits the builder. Finally, all those expert friends shut up when you tell them you built your PC from scratch! The downside is they call you with all there problems after the 1 year store bought PC warranty expires.

Bob, in the beginning of the comments you touched on the subject of different processors. Please note that AMD uses a little different technology that doesn't require extremely high processor frequency to preform at the same level as their counterpart, Intel. I have been highly satisfied with AMD processors and will continue to use them in all of my builds unless requested by a customer to do otherwise.
Note how AMD does label their processors (ex: 2800+, 4200+), this is a good indicator (not the best though) when weighing AMD vs. Intel to see what AMD CPU would be comparable to Intel. 3000+ = 3.0ghz, Athlon vs. Pent. 4, Sempron vs. Celeron. Just my 2 cents. Thanks.