Exploding CDROMs - Comments Page 1

Thanks for writing about exploding CDs... I run an elementary school computer lab and have had several CDs explode while students were using them... this is quite a startling experience, and destroys the disc along with the CD drive.

Since it's impossible to replace these 1996-era CDs, I've taken to collecting the shards and saving them in an empty baby food jar, as proof of ownership of the CD, and then proceed to use a burned copy of the disc. Otherwise, each time this happened, fewer and fewer students would be able to make use of this software.

Strangely, I've only had it happen with a single title-- but it has happened several times with that title!

I'm amazed at this posting, as I have seen your comments on computing and the Internet to be, up till now, perrfectly accurate and reasonable.

This is indeed a myth. The website you link to begins with a flawed premise: That a 64x drive reads at that rotational speed at the innermost track. Not true. CD ROM makers tout their speed on the maximum speeds attainable on the outer tracks.

Alarmist nonsense not befitting your wonderfully factual site, Bob. (Are exploding squirrels next?)

EDITOR'S NOTE: The article referenced does indeed make a distinction between inner and outer track speeds. I suggest you read it again. THIS IS NO MYTH. I've had several people write to me and say they've had CDs explode, too. I'll grant you this doesn't happen often, but
it DOES happen!

I am writing to also state that exploding cd's are real. I had a Windows 98 O/S disc explode and ruin the drive. I did notice that there was a small crack around the center hub but never paid any attention to it, not realizing the great speed the disc spins at. It exploded with a terrific noise and dust. I am very careful to burn a backup copy of any cd's I see that are starting to deteriorate.

Exploding CDs -- I have had a CD self destruct in a clients office. the noise was so loud I thought a steel shelf had fallen down. I no longer use self adhesive labels to mark my CDs. If I cant find my permanent marker I leave the thing unmarked. -- Pearson. Cape Town. SA

Thanks for the info, this just happened to my computer minutes ago. It was a loud explosion, but the shards did not escape the casing luckily. I've fished most of them out, but we're just going to buy a new drive. - White Rock, BC, Canada

My Windows XP Home Edition cd just exploded in my brand new 16X dual layer DVD burner. Largest piece of the disk was no bigger than a dime. I'm returning the drive. I'm hoping Microsoft will replace my disk. If not, I'll be an new Linux user.

I experienced this first hand TWO TIMES. After the said incident, i experienced same problems in both combo drives of mine.

The combo drive can still be detected by the bios and the operating system, but it can't read my cd.
Afetr doing some initial troubleshooting, i discovered that both devices would only attempt to spin the cd thrice at max and stops. It's a shame that i still can't find answer on how to revive both drives, i already asked for technical support but the only thing they offer is replacement which could cost you more than buying a new one. Anyone outhere knows or have an idea on how to revive my combo drives?? please help me.. :) TNX!

Definately not an urban legend, I just went out and replaced a CD-Rom Drive for a client. The pics are the aftermath of the CD and the Drive. I suggest people dont buy slot load CD-Drives due to risk of an emergency trip to the hospital.

See http://anothergoonsite.be/index.php?dir=pics/cd-explode/

Always make backups of original CDs/DVDs and use the backups that way the originals are always intact. Use markers instead of labels because labels have a tendency of wrinkling and peeling off thereby causing and imbalance in the spin. Use Lightscribe media if markers don't cut it.

I Looked Up this web site as my Call of duty Cd has just exploded in my DVD -rom. I nearly had heart attack. it sounded like a gun shot and it took my 20 minutes to locate what had happened. CD/DVD Disc explosions Really Do Happen.