Should I Buy Anti-Spyware or Anti-Virus Software?

Category: Anti-Virus , Security

Should I run AVG, SpyBot, and other freeware, or should I pay for a supposedly better program? I read so much negative about every security program and I am quite confused about them. Some I hear are actually fakes. If they really are worth the money, I am willing to try them. Can you give me your opinion on the best anti-virus, anti-spyware and popup blockers?


Geeks Bearing Gifts?

You are correct to be wary of downloading certain freeware "solutions" for spyware, viruses and popups. There are some excellent free anti-malware tools, but some of the freebies circulating in cyberspace are in fact rogue programs designed to open your computer to a massive invasion of spyware and viruses. One notorious example was Winfixer, which purported to fix all manner of ills on your Windows PC. More recent examples include Antivirus 2010/2011, Win AntiSpyware, and Antivirus 360.

In reality, these fake anti-virus tools are "malware funnels" that only makes things worse. If you get tricked into downloading one of these, you'll probably see popups everywhere, and new viruses coming in by the truckload. See my related article Fake AntiVirus Software for more on that.

Mixing Up a Malware Cocktail

anti-virus anti-spyware

I hear from some readers who run two or three anti-virus programs, and half a dozen anti-spyware tools. Personally, I think that's overkill. WAY overkill. In fact, anti-virus programs can end up fighting with each other, and cause system lockups. And running multiple anti-spyware tools at once WILL slow down your computer.

There are at least a dozen highly touted anti-virus and anti-spyware tools -- some commercial and some free. So I understand your confusion as to which ones are best for you. It's natural to assume that the paid-for variety is of higher quality, but that's not always the case.

Here's my personal arsenal against viruses, spyware and annoying popups:

  • CA Antivirus from Computer Associates (formerly called EZ Anti-VIrus). You can get a 3-month FREE trial, courtesy of Microsoft and Computer Associates. I used this program for several years, with nary a glitch. Scans emails, web pages, downloads and your hard drive for bad stuff. RoadRunner makes this available for free, if you are a customer. After switching service providers, I decided to go with the Free AVG Anti-Virus package and have been very happy with that as well. I'm also impressed with both Avast! and Avira, which are also excellent free anti-virus tools. If you dump the costly resource-hogging Norton or McAfee anti-virus for any of these alternatives, you'll be VERY happy that you did.

  • The FREE MalwareBytes Anti-Malware tool does a great job of scanning your system for spyware and removing infections, especially in situations where something may have slipped past your first line of defense.

  • The FREE Google Toolbar is great at blocking annoying popups. It also adds a handy Google search box to your browser's toolbar, and can automatically fill out web forms.

  • XBlock Systems offers an excellent FREE tool called X-RayPC. I use it as an adjunct to anti-virus and anti-spyware scanners, as a diagnostic tool to help identify questionable processes on a machine. X-RayPC combines the best features of HiJackThis and the SpywareGuide database to show you at a glance EVERY process that's running on your machine, as well as startup programs, browser helper objects (BHOs), toolbars and downloaded program files. The built-in expert system gives you a Good, Bad or Undetermined rating for each, and shows the name of the software developer so you can decide whether to keep or nuke an item. X-RayPC is very easy to use, but since it's powerful enough to remove important files from your computer, I recommend it only for advanced users.

    Works For Me!

    This is what works for me. They're all free, they all come from trusted sources, and they work great. Automatic updates in each program help them keep pace with changes in the malware universe, and I have to say the proof is in the pudding. I do a LOT of web surfing, downloading and email handling. And so far, so good!

    If you have a set of anti-virus, anti-spyware and popup blocker tools that do the trick for you, let us know here. If you use a PAID tool or service, tell us why you think it's better. Post your comments below.

  • Sign up now for AskBob Updates!

    Boost your Internet IQ, keep up with the latest online trends... get your FREE subscription now!


    Email:



    Share this article with friends!


    Posted by on 8 Jan 2006


    Need More Help? Try the AskBobRankin Updates Newsletter. It's Free!

    Prev Article:
    Computer Humor

    The Top Twenty
    Next Article:
    Convert VHS to DVD

    Link to this article from your site or blog. Just copy and paste from this box:


    Most recent comments on "Should I Buy Anti-Spyware or Anti-Virus Software?"

    (See all 163 comments for this article.)

    Posted by:

    Mike McReynolds
    28 Mar 2010

    I have used most of what has been mentioned but MalWare Bytes is beginning to fall by the wayside in my experience. The latest strains of "XP Antivirus", "Antivirus 2010", and other strains of the current wave of fake antivirus infections. The SuperAntiSpyware time and time again has done wonders. The key to fighting any of the fake antivirus strains is to catch them very early, take immediate action, don't even close the pop-up, do a full scan.

    A word about the seeker of Firewall. I tried Comodo's new (free) full security suite as it does include a firewall. I found it a bit on the techie side. You have to tone it down almost to inactive to keep if from asking you every second to "allow" or "deny" a firewall activity. Other than that snafu, it is an excellent program package and the free registration key is good for life! (what ever that is supposed to mean:)If you don't mind a firewall that has a bit of an agressive "learning curve" then it is great for the price.


    Posted by:

    shailesh
    14 Apr 2010

    I am getting svhost.exe error in windows server 2003. how can i kill this application error?


    Posted by:

    Ryan
    15 May 2010

    I use Norton Internet Security 2010 and Windows Defender. Do you think I use enough protection for my PCs, or should I look a different route for Spyware protection?

    EDITOR'S NOTE: In my experience, Defender does a great job. I wouldn't add anything to that combo.


    Posted by:

    Anna
    18 Jun 2010

    The local IT guy who repaired my laptop recently has installed AVIRA and Malwarebytes since the free McAfee Virus Scan Plus which had been supplied by my bank, HSBC, expired around the same time.

    He did say that I could also install Spybot if I want but I saw a criticism about it taking up a lot of memory, so I haven't so far. I'm mindful that it's not advisable to install too many programs as they might clash. I guess I will also have to add anti-Spam for my webmail as my old free Spamfighter only works on Outlook Express which I don't use any more.

    And what about phishing? I'm not covered for that, am I, though I don't think I'm likely to fall for it.


    Posted by:

    Raqq Tuls
    29 Jun 2010

    You're right Bob, too many cooks spoiled the broth. I have only 2 anti-virus and anti-malware installed: Windows Defender which is free, and the other one, Rising anti-virus, which is also free. They both do great jobs. I'm just wondering, why is it that when the other one can't detect a virus or a malware the other one can and vice versa. There was never a time when both of them simultaneously detected the same virus.


    Posted by:

    Bob V
    24 Aug 2010

    Hi Bob, I thought AVG free was fine also until just the other day, for some reason I just decided to open up my AVG suite to check on it and everything had a green checked and all seemed well, then all of a sudden I was attacked and a pop up said I was infected by 34 viruses, trojans and malicious stuff, I couldn't get online, so I had to use my USB stick to get up and going again, I have it loaded with super anit spyware and Malwarebytes and I was ok, I'm adding Windows defender and that will be it.


    Posted by:

    Ron
    08 Sep 2010

    Hello I currently use Microsoft security essentials in conjunction with zone alarm firewall. Please could you reply rating what I use and how to improve. Thank you


    Posted by:

    Ed
    12 Sep 2010

    Hi Bob, I am new to your site and am liking it very much. I wanted to ask you, I am using CA products now. I hear it is very intrusive and slows the system down considerably. Is this correct, and if yes what is good program that I can switch to?

    EDITOR'S NOTE: I used CA anti-virus for years and it worked well. But if you're paying for it, dump it and get one of the freebies I mentioned.


    Posted by:

    Bob M
    08 Nov 2010

    Going to give XRayPC a try. I've also found Malwarebytes, Glary Utilities and two programs from IOBits - Security 350 and Advanced System Care - to be very good.


    Posted by:

    Delmar G Jack
    13 Nov 2010

    Bob; I sure am happy with Avira Security Premium
    Suite. I also have Windows Defender. Is that enough secutity. Thanks. Delmar


    Posted by:

    Gavreil
    18 Nov 2010

    No doubt there are a number of very good free anti-spyware and anti-virus programs, but for the past two years plus, and having tried a number of various programs, I settled on PC Tools Anti-spy-ware with Anti-virus, and I have yet to experience a single problem. Their software has kept my PC free of such problems, as well, they provide warnings about various sites a person may visit unknowingly is a place to stay away from. PC Tools is not free, but I don't feel their being all that costly for one year subscriptions. I will continue to place my trust in PC Tools ability to keep my PC free of hazards.


    Posted by:

    Brian
    26 Nov 2010

    Hi Bob,

    Just to comment on your Anti-Virus suggestions, i totally agree with you on some of the freeware, it is better than the paid versions. having tried Norton 2005, Kaspersky 2010 and Panda, removed all of them as they really did interfere with my system. I now use Advanced System care and AVG 2011, have never looked back. My pc is Windows XP Home SP3


    Posted by:

    Anas
    04 Jan 2011

    I only use Nod 32 buisness edition. Is this a good anti virus software. Its really fast and light. Yeah I need to pay for it but I got a username and password from the torrent and it worked! Now its like free t me then. Tell me that if its a good antivirus tool or not?


    Posted by:

    lindy
    11 Feb 2011

    I had Norton on my new computer (it came free with the new computer and I assumed it was up to date. I connected my computer to the internet and while I was updating the installed Windows, my brand new computer picked up a virus!I hadn't even got a chance to surf ANY sites!

    I got on my old computer and asked for help from Malwarebytes and some unknown person I remain grateful too helped me download Malwarebytes onto a disc which I put into my new computer. I followed their instructions and eventually managed to get my new computer up and running again. But I've never gone on the internet with it again. We only use our old computer on the internet.

    If you know nothing about computers and viruses I would recommend Malwarebytes. It found, quarantined and fixed something that the trial version of the Norton subscription let through. If I can ever afford to splurge on PC protection I'll be subscribing to Malwarebytes because of their goodwill.


    Posted by:

    Wally
    24 Feb 2011

    I hear all of you, including you Bob, saying dump Norton. Sorry, I have to put in my 2 cents for the product. Yes, it may have its faults, but being a slouch on security isn't one of them. Recently, I've been using Norton 360, and consider it well worth the cost. Watch for it on sale, and it can be reasonable. I run at least 4 ram on all my computers and it doesn't seem to slow them. I don't want to compromise when it comes to computer security, I just want the best. Norton 360 does it for me.


    Posted by:

    Kendra
    05 Jun 2011

    Dear Bob,
    You may have been happy with AVG, but my computer IT techie insisted that I run a free virus scan trial using VIPRE b/c he said that AVG is weak and I did and it found 15 harmful things on my computer that AVG and Malwarebytes ignored (incl. 2 Trojans). I knew this stuff was on my computer because of the new toolbars it would force me to use but I didn’t know how to get rid of them. I am willing to pay to have a real virus scan. Try it out and see for yourself. (I am not affiliated with this company, I am just shocked at how much AVG missed and want to warn people). http://www.sunbeltsoftware.com/home-home-office/vipre/Download/


    Posted by:

    sam
    28 Jun 2011

    Very helpful your posts are Bob! Tx! One question I have is what is the difference between an Antivirus software and an Internet security software as we have both these options available in some of them, eg: Kaspersky? I would like to download Avast from all that I hear from your post & comments, but the internet security is not for free. What other free programs would I need to compensate?

    EDITOR'S NOTE: I would suggest adding the following: Anti-spyware, firewall, and spam filtering.


    Posted by:

    a v samikkannu
    02 Jul 2011

    Of all the tech people i have interacted with so far on the net you stand alone as a very good adviser; thank you for your elaborate but quite appropriate postings on this site.
    i have been a netizen for the past 5 years or so with much interest in net-browsing, emailing, net-banking etc. i have been using the Norton Internet Security all these years though , to my utter dismay, it couldn't protect my pc from hang ups & crash downs; as i am afraid of freebies i had gone for the supposedly highest rated i'net security software; the other reason is that the Norton people are quick to help you online.


    Posted by:

    Dave in Indy
    06 Dec 2011

    I've been told to dump Norton (employer provided), skip AVG and the other free AV titles and download MSE. Would be interested in your opinions of MSE. Thanks!


    Posted by:

    Stephen G
    02 Apr 2012

    Hey Bob,

    Glad to see your decision to dump Norton. We advise all of our computer repair clients inGrand Rapids to go with AVG over a paid Antivirus program.

    Thank you for the tips!


    There's more reader feedback... See all 163 comments for this article.

    Post your Comments, Questions or Suggestions

    *     *     (* = Required field)

        (Your email address will not be published)
    (you may use HTML tags for style)

    YES... spelling, punctuation, grammar and proper use of UPPER/lower case are important! And please limit your remarks to 3-4 paragraphs. If you want to see your comment posted, pay attention to these items.

    All comments are previewed, and may be edited before posting.

    NOTE: Please, post comments on this article ONLY.
    If you want to ask a question click here.


    Free Tech Support -- Ask Bob Rankin
    RSS   Add to My Yahoo!   Feedburner Feed
    Subscribe to AskBobRankin Updates: Free Newsletter
    Copyright © 2005 - Bob Rankin - All Rights Reserved
    Privacy Policy -- See my profile on Google.


    Article information: AskBobRankin -- Should I Buy Anti-Spyware or Anti-Virus Software? (Posted: 8 Jan 2006)
    Source: http://askbobrankin.com/should_i_buy_antispyware_or_antivirus_software.html
    Copyright © 2005 - Bob Rankin - All Rights Reserved

     
    Free
    Newsletter
    Get the FREE  "AskBob Updates" newsletter!       Email:    (Details)