Penny Auctions: Legit or Scam?

Category: Shopping

You've probably seen those ads, offering popular electronic gadgets for insanely low prices. You know, the lady who brags about getting a 60-inch HDTV for thirty bucks? These so-called 'penny auction' websites offer products for pennies on the dollar. Are they a big scam, or a legitimate way to save money? Let's take a look at how penny auctions work...

What Is a Penny Auction?

I'd really like to meet the guy who bought that brand new 64GB Apple iPad for $2.49 at an online auction site. Maybe he'll sell it to me for five dollars. Sites like QuiBids, OrangeBidz, and DealDash offer popular products for prices that just don't seem possible. But the sellers are definitely making money on these deals. Here's how penny auctions, also known as bidding fee auctions, operate.

In a traditional online auction at a site like eBay, it's free to bid, and the price of the item goes up as people try to outbid each other. Most of the time, the winner of the auction pays a price that's reasonably close to the value of the item, due to competition and rational bidding. The "losers" pay nothing, and get nothing. It's a pretty simple and fair model.

In a penny auction, opening prices are set unusually low, whetting the potential buyer's appetite for a bargain. A non-refundable fee is charged for the privilege of placing a bid. Each new high bid raises the going price by a small amount – often a penny, although it may be more. Each new high bid also extends the ending time of the auction by a few seconds, giving others an opportunity to outbid the high bidder. The auction ends when its ending time passes without a new bid.

Penny Auctions: Scam or Legit?

It’s entirely possible to spend more money on bids than on the item you win. But all you will see when you look at penny auction histories are the low opening prices and the relatively low winning bids. You don’t see how much the winners spent on bid fees. The lack of this hidden information misleads people into believing that they can get fantastic bargains.

Let's Do the Math

Here's a simplified example of a penny auction for a laptop that retails for $1000. You have a group of bidders, each paying a dollar to place a bid, and every bid raises the price of the item by a penny. If the winning bidder placed 60 bids, and the final price of the auction was $50, he or she would pay a total of $110 for the laptop, and save $890. What a deal!

But what about all the bids placed by the other hopeful bidders? Well, a final price of $50 means a total of 5000 bids were placed. So the seller (probably the auction site) gets $5050, minus the $1000 cost of the laptop, or a profit of $4050. The bottom line: one lucky winning buyer, one seller with an enormous profit, and lots of losing bidders, many of whom paid $30, $40, or $50, and got nothing.

If you want to save money while shopping online, skip the penny auction slot machine and see my article 10 Money Saving Tips For Holiday Shoppers. You'll find some tips and tools to compare prices, find coupons, and get rebates.

Keeping it Simple

Most people like to keep their purchases simple. Tell me what a product costs and I’ll decide whether I want to pay the price. But some people want to save money so badly that they’ll endure more complexity, like bidding on an auction item repeatedly. A few are so cost-conscious that they’ll pay for the mere hope of saving money AND endure the complexities of an auction. That last group is the most susceptible to fraud because their greed blinds them to reality. Penny auctions take advantage of greed.

It is possible, in theory, to get a fantastic bargain if a) the bid fee is low and b) you bid rationally. Place one bid that represents the highest amount you are willing to pay for the item; then ignore the auction until it ends. If you win, great; if not, look for another opportunity. But many penny auction systems are rigged so that you will never win by bidding rationally.

Most penny auction sites make participants buy bundles of bids for a relatively high price. Quibids, for example charges new users a minimum of $60 for a "bid pack" of 150 bids. You start out in the hole, and the only way to (possibly) get ahead is to keep bidding. The site wants you to keep bidding because that drives up the winning bid. In a way, participating in a penny auction is like gambling. You repeatedly put up a small sum of money, in the hopes of winning a big payoff, at odds that favor the house. The irony is the odds are probably better in Vegas than at a penny auction.

Beware of Shills and Robots

Shill bidding also happens, and is sometimes automated. You place a high bid and almost instantly, someone else outbids you. Your competition works for the seller; the competitor may even be a software program or “bidbot.” If you succumb to “bidding frenzy” in an effort to win the item, you will end up paying whatever the seller wants you to pay. If you don’t win against a shill, you are still out the cost of the bid fees.

If you do buy into a penny auction, look for signs of shill or automated bidding. Fake usernames are often unimaginative and artificial; “bidder14” or “suzysue” are something a bidbot might generate randomly. Very fast responses to your bids are another clue, although bidbots may be programmed to wait until just before time expires on an auction to bid and extend it.

Like casinos, most penny auctions sites play by the rules, and don't use shills or bidbots. Those rules are designed to bring them huge profits, so there's little incentive for established penny auction sites to cheat. And after a few such sites were shut down by authorities, they know the law is watching.

Penny auctions are legal, but so are slot machines. My advice is to keep buying simple. Avoid the temptation to be sucked into bidding wars, and never pay for the mere hope of getting a bargain. Remember the wry wisdom of experienced auction players: “The winner of an auction is the one who pays more than anyone else thinks something is worth for something the seller didn’t think was worth keeping.”

What's your opinion of penny auctions? Post your comment or question below...

Ask Your Computer or Internet Question

  (Enter your question in the box above.)

It's Guaranteed to Make You Smarter...

AskBob Updates: Boost your Internet IQ & solve computer problems.
Get your FREE Subscription!


Check out other articles in this category:

Link to this article from your site or blog. Just copy and paste from this box:

This article was posted by on 2 Dec 2019

For Fun: Buy Bob a Snickers.

Prev Article:
10 Money Saving Tips For Holiday Shoppers

The Top Twenty
Next Article:
Try These Free Cloud Services

Most recent comments on "Penny Auctions: Legit or Scam?"

Posted by:

02 Dec 2019

I'd say, it's a legit scam. Works like lottery. Around 10 years ago I calculated whole scheme for a Cusinart toster (MSRP $59.99, as I remember), the winner have got it for around $30, but the auction in the process received around $3,500 (three thousand five hundred bucks). This amount came from all bids for that item that was made during that auction. I don't remember all details, but the bid was 1 penny, but you have to pay several pennies for every penny. So overall all money that were paid for all bids came to that huge amount around $3,500. Now I can recalculate around $210, but look like I forgot some important details. But anyway, $210 (for every penny bid for 6 cents) for $59.99 thing is a pretty good deal.

Just ran through Bob's math - exactly what I did then - very clear explanation, thanks, Bob!

Posted by:

02 Dec 2019

Also, I've noticed in the ads for some of those sites that "you are guaranteed to win your first auction!" Nothing suspicious there . . .

Posted by:

02 Dec 2019

When I first heard about the "penny" auction, I thought, it seems too good to be true. Many times I have used that question before buying anything that, on the face of it, should be worth much more that is being asked -- Is it too good to be true? Before I wised-up, I purchased a couple of lemons.
I see similar questionable offerings via click-bait adds. One example was for a chainsaw that I was looking to buy. A click-bait ad indicated a price of $65, including shipping, for a chainsaw that normally retails for $350.00. I tried researching the company but found nothing. Hence, To Good To Be True.

Posted by:

03 Dec 2019

Thanks for the clarity: it's simply a scam.

Posted by:

Nascar 68117
03 Dec 2019

By now ,I would presume that us buyers [from web sites] have seen ,to stay away from any of those auction web sites ,for the same reason you mentioned.
The proceeding bidder losses his [her] $30.00 on the next bid.

Posted by:

03 Dec 2019

Generally, there is the principle of caveat emptor - Let the purchaser beware! Also, if it sounds too good to be true, the probability is quite high that it IS too good to be true! Thank you for the informative article!

Posted by:

03 Dec 2019

Sounds like I am being shamed for being a regular shopper at TopHatter and maybe even Wish. Caveat Emptor has always been my motto even at sites like eBay and CraigsList.

EDITOR'S NOTE: No shame! If they work well for you, it's a win.

Posted by:

03 Dec 2019

I always knew that I should avoid these auctions. Now I know why. Thank you.

Posted by:

Bob Kinsler
03 Dec 2019

There is a gentleman (actually a retired US Army type) that uses DealDash around here.

He bid on a FIT Vehicle (I understand it is a GM Product) and got it for around $5K, then sold it back to the dealer for $11K netting a profit for himself. (I got involved because he asked me for taxing advice, had to tell him that $6K was income and taxable).

Post your Comments, Questions or Suggestions

*     *     (* = Required field)

    (Your email address will not be published)
(you may use HTML tags for style)

YES... spelling, punctuation, grammar and proper use of UPPER/lower case are important! Comments of a political nature are discouraged. Please limit your remarks to 3-4 paragraphs. If you want to see your comment posted, pay attention to these items.

All comments are reviewed, and may be edited or removed at the discretion of the moderator.

NOTE: Please, post comments on this article ONLY.
If you want to ask a question click here.

Free Tech Support -- Ask Bob Rankin
Subscribe to AskBobRankin Updates: Free Newsletter

Copyright © 2005 - Bob Rankin - All Rights Reserved
About Us     Privacy Policy     RSS/XML

Article information: AskBobRankin -- Penny Auctions: Legit or Scam? (Posted: 2 Dec 2019)
Copyright © 2005 - Bob Rankin - All Rights Reserved